| St Augustine's Catholic Primary School Faith | Good2024 | 4.6 applications per place | 71% | 7% |
| Holy Family Catholic Primary School Faith | Remains Good2023 | 3.8 applications per place | 77% | 13% |
| St Mary's Catholic Primary School, Barnard Castle Faith | Standards maintained2024 | 3.1small intake applications per place | 81% | 22% |
| St Mary's Catholic Primary School, Newton Aycliffe Faith | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.9small intake applications per place | 66% | 47% |
| St Cuthbert's Catholic Primary School, Crook Faith | Standards maintained2025 | 2.8small intake applications per place | 69% | 37% |
| St Gregory's Catholic Academy Faith | 2026 | 2.6 applications per place | 67% | 23% |
| St Patrick's Catholic Primary School, Stockton Faith | Good2024 | 2.5 applications per place | 62% | 8% |
| Sacred Heart Catholic Primary School, Hartlepool Faith | Good2023 | 2.3 applications per place | 77% | 23% |
| St Teresa's Catholic Primary School Faith | Remains Good2024 | 2.2 applications per place | 85% | 11% |
| St Bede's Catholic Academy Faith | 2025 | 2.2 applications per place | 68% | 54% |
| St Bega's Catholic Primary School, Hartlepool Faith | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.1 applications per place | 71% | 41% |
| Our Lady and St Thomas Catholic Primary School, Willington Faith | Good2023 | 2.1small intake applications per place | 50% | 26% |
| St John Vianney Catholic Primary School, Hartlepool Faith | Outstanding2024 | 2.1 applications per place | 86% | 27% |
| St Paul's Catholic Primary School Faith | Graded · no overall grade2024 | 2.1 applications per place | 75% | 5% |
| St Bede's Catholic Primary School Faith | Graded · no overall grade2024 | 2.0 applications per place | 64% | 12% |
| St Joseph's Catholic Primary School, Hartlepool Faith | Good2023 | 1.9small intake applications per place | 71% | 55% |
| St John the Evangelist Catholic Primary School Faith | 2026 | 1.8small intake applications per place | 59% | 31% |
| St Chad's Catholic Primary School, Witton Park Faith | Good2023 | 1.8small intake applications per place | 67% | 30% |
| St Joseph's Catholic Primary School Faith | Good2022 | 1.8 applications per place | 84% | 41% |
| Our Lady of the Most Holy Rosary Catholic Academy Faith | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.8 applications per place | 71% | 37% |
| St Charles' Catholic Primary School, Tudhoe Faith | Remains Good2024 | 1.7 applications per place | 73% | 14% |
| St Teresa's Catholic Primary School Faith | Remains Good2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 47% | 24% |
| St Cuthbert's Catholic Primary School, Hartlepool Faith | Remains Good2024 | 1.7 applications per place | 70% | 30% |
| St Joseph's Catholic Academy Faith | Remains Good2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 56% | 13% |
| St Wilfrid's Catholic Primary School, Bishop Auckland Faith | Standards maintained2025 | 1.6 applications per place | 40% | 50% |
| St Cuthbert's Catholic Primary School, Stockton Faith | Remains Good2024 | 1.6 applications per place | 53% | 33% |
| Blessed John Duckett Catholic Primary School, Tow Law Faith | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.6small intake applications per place | 11% | 34% |
| St Joseph's Catholic Primary School Faith | Remains Good2024 | 1.5 applications per place | 67% | 28% |
| St William's Catholic Primary School Faith | Good2024 | 1.4 applications per place | 60% | 17% |
| St Joseph's Catholic Primary School, Coundon Faith | Requires improvement2024 | 1.4small intake applications per place | 70% | 46% |