| Gawber Primary School | Outstanding2024 | 4.0 applications per place | 80% | 6% |
| Dodworth St John the Baptist CofE Primary Academy Faith | Requires improvement2023 | 3.4small intake applications per place | 59% | 23% |
| Cawthorne Church of England Voluntary Controlled Primary School Faith | Good2024 | 3.2 applications per place | 83% | 1% |
| Springvale Primary School | Remains Good2023 | 3.0 applications per place | 80% | 12% |
| Lacewood Primary School | Good2023 | 2.9 applications per place | 67% | 33% |
| Summer Lane Primary | Special measures Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.8 applications per place | – | 18% |
| Oxspring Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 2.8 applications per place | 78% | 10% |
| Silkstone Common Junior and Infant School | Good2022 | 2.8 applications per place | 84% | 7% |
| Elsecar Holy Trinity CofE Primary Academy Faith | Remains Good2024 | 2.7 applications per place | 68% | 23% |
| Cherry Dale Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.6 applications per place | 63% | 35% |
| Parkside Primary Academy | Remains Good2024 | 2.6 applications per place | 72% | 28% |
| Mapplewell Primary School | Good2024 | 2.6 applications per place | 76% | 13% |
| Highgate Primary Academy | Remains Good2022 | 2.6 applications per place | 75% | 45% |
| Hoylandswaine Primary School | Special measures Inadequate2022 | 2.5small intake applications per place | 85% | 9% |
| Wombwell Park Street Primary School | Remains Good2023 | 2.4 applications per place | 57% | 24% |
| Hoyland Common Primary School | Good2022 | 2.4 applications per place | 66% | 17% |
| Shawlands Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 2.4 applications per place | 64% | 21% |
| Churchfield Primary School | Good2024 | 2.4 applications per place | 80% | 30% |
| Heather Garth Primary School Academy | 2026 | 2.3 applications per place | 63% | 37% |
| Summerfields Primary Academy | Good2023 | 2.3 applications per place | 88% | 15% |
| Darton Primary School | Remains Good2022 | 2.3 applications per place | 58% | 18% |
| Lift St Helen's | Good2024 | 2.3 applications per place | 62% | 35% |
| Hoyland Springwood Primary School | Remains Good2023 | 2.2small intake applications per place | 48% | 52% |
| Birdwell Primary School | 2026 | 2.2 applications per place | 85% | 21% |
| Millhouse Primary School | Good2023 | 2.2 applications per place | 73% | 17% |
| Outwood Primary Academy Darfield | Good2024 | 2.2 applications per place | 76% | 33% |
| Barugh Green Primary School | Good2024 | 2.2 applications per place | 67% | 11% |
| Oakwell Rise Primary Academy | 2026 | 2.2 applications per place | 81% | 43% |
| Athersley South Primary School | Standards maintained2024 | 2.2 applications per place | 66% | 40% |
| Silkstone Primary School | Good2023 | 2.1 applications per place | 83% | 7% |
| Lift Shafton | Improved significantly2024 | 2.1 applications per place | 59% | 26% |
| Kings Oak Primary | Standards maintained2025 | 2.1 applications per place | – | 33% |
| Greenfield Primary School | Remains Good2023 | 2.1 applications per place | – | 33% |
| West Meadows Primary School | 2026 | 2.1 applications per place | 55% | 41% |
| Carrfield Primary Academy | Remains Good2023 | 2.1 applications per place | 63% | 37% |
| Thurgoland Church of England (Voluntary Controlled) Primary School Faith | Good2022 | 2.0 applications per place | 87% | 8% |
| Wellgate Primary School | Improved significantly2025 | 2.0 applications per place | 72% | 24% |
| Laithes Primary School | 2026 | 2.0 applications per place | 68% | 49% |
| Carlton Primary Academy | Good2023 | 1.9 applications per place | 64% | 19% |
| Lift Meadstead | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.9 applications per place | 68% | 44% |
| Tankersley St Peter's CofE (Aided) Primary School Faith | Remains Good2023 | 1.9 applications per place | 81% | 10% |
| Bank End Primary Academy | 2026 | 1.9 applications per place | 92% | 47% |
| Birkwood Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2024 | 1.9 applications per place | 61% | 33% |
| Thurlstone Primary School | Good2023 | 1.9 applications per place | 37% | 8% |
| Sacred Heart Catholic Primary School Faith | Some aspects not as strong2025 | 1.9 applications per place | 35% | 27% |
| Ward Green Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2024 | 1.9 applications per place | 63% | 29% |
| High View Primary Learning Centre | Good2024 | 1.8 applications per place | 64% | 37% |
| Keresforth Primary School | Good2022 | 1.8 applications per place | 73% | 16% |
| Ladywood Primary School | Remains Good2023 | 1.8 applications per place | 52% | 34% |
| Hunningley Primary Academy | Outstanding2023 | 1.8 applications per place | 87% | 37% |
| Joseph Locke Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 1.8 applications per place | 75% | 32% |
| Kexborough Primary School | Standards maintained2025 | 1.8 applications per place | 57% | 25% |
| All Saints Academy Darfield Faith | Requires improvement2024 | 1.8 applications per place | 57% | 40% |
| St Mary's Church of England Primary School, Barnsley Faith | Good2024 | 1.8 applications per place | 51% | 9% |
| Worsbrough Common Primary School | Good2024 | 1.8 applications per place | 66% | 32% |
| The Forest Academy | Outstanding2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 70% | 42% |
| Upperwood Academy | Standards maintained2025 | 1.7 applications per place | 66% | 29% |
| Queens Road Academy | Remains Good2022 | 1.7 applications per place | 54% | 28% |
| Brierley Church of England Voluntary Controlled Primary School Faith | Good2024 | 1.7 applications per place | 86% | 21% |
| Burton Road Primary School | Remains Good2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 76% | 17% |
| St Helen's Catholic Primary School Faith | Remains Good2023 | 1.7small intake applications per place | 0% | 41% |
| Holy Rood Catholic Primary School Faith | Standards maintained2024 | 1.7 applications per place | 53% | 23% |
| Wilthorpe Primary School | Good2024 | 1.7 applications per place | 71% | 19% |
| Goldthorpe Primary Academy | Good2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 68% | 49% |
| Oakhill Primary Academy | Standards maintained2024 | 1.7 applications per place | 69% | 24% |
| Penistone St John's Voluntary Aided Primary School Faith | Good2024 | 1.6 applications per place | 74% | 14% |
| Athersley North Primary School | 2026 | 1.6 applications per place | 49% | 56% |
| Royston St John Baptist CE Primary Faith | Good2022 | 1.6 applications per place | 55% | 28% |
| Gooseacre Primary Academy | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.6 applications per place | 69% | 42% |
| The Mill Academy | Remains Good2022 | 1.6 applications per place | 63% | 42% |
| The Hill Primary Academy | Good2023 | 1.5 applications per place | 64% | 56% |
| Milefield Primary School | Good2024 | 1.4 applications per place | 67% | 38% |
| The Ellis Church of England Primary School Faith | Good2022 | 1.4 applications per place | – | 10% |
| St Michael and All Angels Catholic Primary School Faith | Remains Good2024 | 1.4 applications per place | 50% | 29% |
| Outwood Primary Academy Littleworth Grange | Remains Good2024 | 1.3 applications per place | 66% | 42% |
| Sandhill Primary School | Good2024 | 1.2 applications per place | 62% | 44% |
| Jump Primary Academy | Good2024 | no data | – | – |