| Broomhill Infant School | Good2023 | 4.0 applications per place | – | 12% |
| Loxley Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 3.9 applications per place | 87% | 11% |
| Totley All Saints Church of England Voluntary Aided Primary School Faith | 2026 | 3.4 applications per place | 81% | 9% |
| Rivelin Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 3.4 applications per place | 66% | 19% |
| Clifford All Saints CofE Primary School Faith | Requires improvement2021 | 3.2small intake applications per place | 65% | 12% |
| Meersbrook Bank Primary School | 2026 | 3.2 applications per place | 57% | 9% |
| Nether Green Infant School | Remains Good2023 | 3.1 applications per place | – | 10% |
| Bradfield Dungworth Primary School | Remains Good2023 | 3.0small intake applications per place | 90% | 8% |
| St Mary's Church of England Primary School Faith | Good2022 | 2.9small intake applications per place | 71% | 35% |
| Ecclesall Primary School | Good2023 | 2.9 applications per place | – | 4% |
| Norton Free Church of England Primary School Faith | Good2023 | 2.8 applications per place | 78% | 19% |
| Coit Primary School | Good2024 | 2.8 applications per place | 64% | 13% |
| Lound Infant School | Remains Good2022 | 2.7 applications per place | – | 16% |
| Lowfield Community Primary School | Remains Good2022 | 2.7 applications per place | 62% | 40% |
| Mosborough Primary School | Outstanding2023 | 2.7 applications per place | 69% | 14% |
| Wisewood Nursery & Primary School | 2026 | 2.7 applications per place | 68% | 45% |
| Woodseats Primary School | Good2024 | 2.6 applications per place | 60% | 31% |
| Totley Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.6 applications per place | 92% | 8% |
| Mundella Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.6 applications per place | – | 13% |
| Dore Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.5 applications per place | 82% | 7% |
| Lydgate Infant School | Remains Good2023 | 2.5 applications per place | – | 9% |
| Nether Edge Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.5 applications per place | 80% | 28% |
| St Joseph's Primary School Faith | Good2024 | 2.5 applications per place | 30% | 13% |
| Marlcliffe Community Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 2.4 applications per place | 71% | 14% |
| St Marie's School, A Catholic Voluntary Academy Faith | Remains Good2022 | 2.4 applications per place | 76% | 16% |
| Hillsborough Nursery & Primary School | 2026 | 2.4 applications per place | 64% | 46% |
| Holt House Infant School | Good2022 | 2.4 applications per place | – | 15% |
| Netherthorpe Primary School | 2026 | 2.3 applications per place | 57% | 52% |
| Porter Croft Church of England Primary Academy Faith | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.3 applications per place | 50% | 41% |
| St Wilfrid's Catholic Primary School Faith | Good2022 | 2.3 applications per place | 77% | 5% |
| Malin Bridge Primary School | Remains Outstanding2024 | 2.3 applications per place | 71% | 20% |
| St Theresa's Catholic Primary School Faith | Remains Good2023 | 2.3 applications per place | 42% | 22% |
| Wharncliffe Side Primary School and Nursery | Good2022 | 2.3 applications per place | 61% | 35% |
| Carfield Primary School | 2026 | 2.3 applications per place | 78% | 26% |
| Windmill Hill Primary School | Remains Good2022 | 2.2 applications per place | 44% | 19% |
| St Thomas More Catholic Primary, A Voluntary Academy Faith | Remains Good2024 | 2.2 applications per place | 57% | 20% |
| Abbey Lane Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 2.2 applications per place | – | 16% |
| Bradway Primary School | Remains Good2022 | 2.2 applications per place | 62% | 15% |
| Dobcroft Nursery Infant School | Good2021 | 2.2 applications per place | – | 4% |
| Prince Edward Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 2.2 applications per place | 78% | 46% |
| Westways Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 2.1 applications per place | 73% | 16% |
| St Catherine's Catholic Primary School (Hallam) Faith | Remains Outstanding2022 | 2.1 applications per place | 75% | 37% |
| St Patrick's Catholic Voluntary Academy Faith | Special measures Graded · no overall grade2024 | 2.1 applications per place | 8% | 33% |
| Ballifield Primary School | Remains Good2022 | 2.1 applications per place | 59% | 19% |
| High Green Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2024 | 2.1 applications per place | 43% | 17% |
| Springfield Primary School | Standards maintained2024 | 2.1 applications per place | 43% | 37% |
| Ecclesfield Primary School | Good2024 | 2.0 applications per place | 51% | 31% |
| Fox Hill Primary | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.0 applications per place | 13% | 61% |
| Grenoside Community Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 2.0 applications per place | 65% | 22% |
| St Ann's Catholic Primary School, A Voluntary Academy Faith | Standards maintained2025 | 2.0small intake applications per place | 50% | 20% |
| Charnock Hall Primary Academy | Standards maintained2025 | 2.0 applications per place | 71% | 18% |
| St Thomas of Canterbury School, a Catholic Voluntary Academy Faith | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 2.0 applications per place | 67% | 18% |
| Angram Bank Primary School | 2026 | 1.9 applications per place | 72% | 43% |
| Phillimore Community Primary School | Good2023 | 1.9 applications per place | 49% | 55% |
| Hatfield Academy | Good2023 | 1.9 applications per place | 35% | 56% |
| Lowedges Primary Academy | Good2023 | 1.9 applications per place | 59% | 71% |
| Hallam Nursery & Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.9 applications per place | 76% | 9% |
| Reignhead Primary School | Some aspects not as strong2024 | 1.9 applications per place | 36% | 34% |
| Gleadless Primary School | Requires improvement2022 | 1.9 applications per place | 49% | 31% |
| St Mary's Primary School, A Catholic Voluntary Academy Faith | 2026 | 1.9 applications per place | 79% | 11% |
| Anns Grove Primary School | Remains Good2020 | 1.9 applications per place | 69% | 34% |
| Halfway Nursery Infant School | Remains Good2024 | 1.9 applications per place | – | 21% |
| Greenhill Primary School | Good2022 | 1.9 applications per place | 38% | 39% |
| Arbourthorne Community Primary School | Good2022 | 1.8 applications per place | 42% | 68% |
| Hartley Brook Primary School | Good2024 | 1.8 applications per place | 44% | 62% |
| Intake Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 1.8 applications per place | 61% | 35% |
| Norfolk Community Primary School | Good2022 | 1.8 applications per place | 36% | 63% |
| Parson Cross Church of England Primary School Faith | Good2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 36% | 30% |
| Stradbroke Primary School | Remains Good2022 | 1.7 applications per place | 59% | 52% |
| Birley Spa Primary Academy | Requires improvement2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 63% | 50% |
| Abbeyfield Primary Academy | Graded · no overall grade2024 | 1.7 applications per place | 59% | 48% |
| Byron Wood Primary Academy | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.7 applications per place | 41% | 56% |
| Manor Lodge Community Primary and Nursery School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.7 applications per place | 50% | 42% |
| Acres Hill Community Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.7 applications per place | 45% | 55% |
| Oughtibridge Primary School | Outstanding2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 84% | 9% |
| Rainbow Forge Primary Academy | Good2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 45% | 47% |
| Sacred Heart School, A Catholic Voluntary Academy Faith | 2026 | 1.7 applications per place | 69% | 20% |
| Emmaus Catholic and CofE Primary School Faith | Good2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 33% | 47% |
| Meynell Nursery & Primary School | Good2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 61% | 68% |
| Athelstan Primary School | Remains Good2023 | 1.7 applications per place | 73% | 32% |
| Stannington Infant School | Outstanding2023 | 1.6 applications per place | – | 13% |
| Walkley Primary School | Good2023 | 1.6 applications per place | 67% | 25% |
| Watercliffe Meadow Community Primary School | Standards maintained2025 | 1.6 applications per place | 68% | 58% |
| Whiteways Primary School | Standards maintained2024 | 1.6 applications per place | 57% | 61% |
| E-ACT Pathways Academy | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.6 applications per place | 62% | 64% |
| Brunswick Community Primary School | Remains Good2023 | 1.6 applications per place | 54% | 33% |
| St John Fisher Primary, A Catholic Voluntary Academy Faith | Standards maintained2024 | 1.6 applications per place | 81% | 20% |
| Mansel Primary | Good2023 | 1.6 applications per place | 40% | 55% |
| Stocksbridge Nursery Infant School | Standards maintained2025 | 1.6 applications per place | – | 23% |
| Waterthorpe Infant School | Good2024 | 1.6 applications per place | – | 27% |
| Monteney Primary School | Good2023 | 1.5 applications per place | 45% | 37% |
| Birley Primary Academy | Standards maintained2025 | 1.5 applications per place | 62% | 28% |
| Pipworth Community Primary School | Good2024 | 1.5 applications per place | 64% | 60% |
| Wybourn Community Primary & Nursery School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.5 applications per place | 38% | 71% |
| Greengate Lane Academy | Remains Good2024 | 1.5 applications per place | 85% | 57% |
| Shortbrook Primary School | Good2023 | 1.5small intake applications per place | 90% | 65% |
| Woodlands Primary School | Good2022 | 1.5 applications per place | 39% | 63% |
| Brightside Nursery Infant School | Outstanding2024 | 1.5 applications per place | – | 36% |
| Oasis Academy Watermead | Graded · no overall grade2025 | 1.5 applications per place | 70% | 55% |
| Woodhouse West Primary School | Graded · no overall grade2024 | 1.5 applications per place | 46% | 57% |
| Royd Nursery and Infant School | Graded · no overall grade2024 | 1.5 applications per place | – | 20% |
| Woodthorpe Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 1.4 applications per place | 63% | 63% |
| Hucklow Primary School | Good2024 | 1.4 applications per place | 55% | 48% |
| Pye Bank CofE Primary School Faith | Good2022 | 1.4 applications per place | 55% | 60% |
| Bankwood Primary School | Special measures 2026 | 1.4 applications per place | 54% | 72% |
| High Hazels Nursery Infant Academy | Remains Good2023 | 1.4 applications per place | – | 53% |
| Lower Meadow Primary School | Standards maintained2025 | 1.4 applications per place | 45% | 72% |
| Oasis Academy Fir Vale | 2026 | 1.4 applications per place | 37% | 83% |
| Owler Brook Primary School | Remains Good2024 | 1.4 applications per place | 48% | 71% |
| Beck Primary School | Good2024 | 1.3 applications per place | 30% | 56% |
| Beighton Nursery Infant School | Good2024 | 1.3 applications per place | – | 15% |
| Brigantia Hill Fort Academy | Not yet inspected | 1.3 applications per place | – | 42% |
| Southey Green Nursery & Primary School | 2026 | 1.3 applications per place | 64% | 56% |
| Tinsley Meadows Primary School | Good2023 | 1.0 applications per place | 54% | 54% |
| Brook House Junior | Good2022 | no data | 48% | 23% |
| Carter Knowle Junior School | Standards maintained2024 | no data | 80% | 18% |
| Chapeltown Academy | Not yet inspected | no data | – | 0% |
| Deepcar St John's Church of England Junior School Faith | Good2024 | no data | 66% | 31% |
| Dobcroft Junior School | 2026 | no data | – | – |
| Emmanuel Anglican/Methodist Junior Academy Faith | Remains Good2023 | no data | 59% | 43% |
| Greystones Primary School | Remains Good2022 | no data | – | – |
| Halfway Junior School | 2026 | no data | 69% | 33% |
| High Hazels Junior School | Standards maintained2025 | no data | 65% | 61% |
| Hunter's Bar Infant School | Remains Good2023 | no data | – | – |
| Hunter's Bar Junior School | Standards maintained2024 | no data | – | – |
| Limpsfield Junior School | Good2022 | no data | – | – |
| Longley Park Sixth Form Academy | Not yet inspected | no data | – | 0% |
| Lound Junior School | Remains Good2022 | no data | 63% | 18% |
| Lydgate Junior School | Remains Good2023 | no data | 65% | 11% |
| Nether Green Junior School | Standards maintained2024 | no data | 60% | 13% |
| Nook Lane Junior School | Remains Good2023 | no data | 58% | 16% |
| Sharrow Nursery, Infant and Junior School | Remains Good2024 | no data | – | – |
| Shooters Grove Nursery and Primary School | Remains Good2022 | no data | – | – |
| Stocksbridge Junior School | Graded · no overall grade2025 | no data | 70% | 28% |